Firm Events
District Court vs. PTAB: Strategic Forum Selection in Life Sciences Patent Disputes
December 10, 2026 | 12:00 PM – 1:00 PM ET
The regulatory landscape governing employment eligibility verification has shifted dramatically. For the first time in more than a decade, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has updated its Form I-9 inspection guidance, reclassifying a wide range of technical errors that were previously considered minor — and curable — as serious, punishable violations. At the same time, worksite enforcement activity is on the rise, with ICE conducting worksite compliance investigations at an increasing pace.
For employers, the message is clear: I-9 compliance is no longer a back-burner HR task or niche concern. It is an enterprise-level legal and financial risk requiring proactive attention and robust internal processes.
Under longstanding ICE enforcement policy, I-9 errors fell into one of two categories: technical violations, which were minor paperwork errors that could be corrected within a 10-business-day window to avoid a fine; and substantive violations, which were the more serious errors that triggered immediate penalties with no opportunity for correction.
ICE’s recent Fact Sheet fundamentally reshapes this framework. Many errors that were considered technical are now considered substantive, meaning that upon inspection they immediately trigger fines.
Employee Information in Section 1:
Employer Information in Section 2 and Supplement B:
Preparer/Translator Certification, Supplement A:
Remote Inspection and Alternative Procedure:
Electronic I-9 Systems:
Overall Completion Requirements:
Spanish-Language Form:
Employee Information in Section 1:
Employer Information in Section 2:
Supplements A and B:
Previously, if an employer failed to record required document information in Section 2 of the I-9, ICE often treated this as curable if the employer maintained a legible photocopy of the document on file.
That safe harbor is no longer in place. Under ICE’s new guidance, omissions in these fields are substantive violations even if photocopies of the documents are on file. Employers who relied on this practice as a backstop must now ensure their data entry is complete and accurate at the time of onboarding.
The practical consequence of the reclassification is straightforward: more, and more potentially costly, violations per Form I-9. More Forms I-9 with violations push employers into higher penalty tiers; for large employers or those with high workforce turnover, the aggregate exposure can reach six or seven figures from a single audit.
Thus, the time to fix I-9 errors is now: before the audit notice arrives.
Given the heightened enforcement environment and expanded penalty exposure, employers should consider the following steps:
1. Elevate I-9 Compliance to an Enterprise Priority
Treat Form I-9 compliance as a company-wide legal and financial risk. Ensure that senior leadership, compliance teams, and internal audit functions understand the updated enforcement landscape.
2. Conduct an Internal I-9 Audit
Conduct an internal audit of I-9 records to identify errors and assess the current error rate and potential fine exposure. Develop a prioritized remediation plan targeting time-sensitive violations, high-risk locations, and employee groups, etc.
3. Strengthen Training and Standardize Procedures
Provide targeted training to all staff who complete or reverify I-9 forms, with a focus on:
Implementation of standardized checklists for onboarding and reverification can reduce inconsistency and human error.
4. Review Electronic I-9 Platforms
Confirm that any electronic I-9 system and e-signature tools the organization uses comply with applicable regulatory requirements. Specifically:
5. Prepare an ICE Response Protocol
Instead of waiting until ICE arrives, consider taking the following steps now:
This just in
Firm Events
District Court vs. PTAB: Strategic Forum Selection in Life Sciences Patent Disputes
December 10, 2026 | 12:00 PM – 1:00 PM ET
Speaking Engagements
Performance on Trial: The Construction Manager’s Standard of Care Examined from All Angles
December 2, 2026 | 4:15 PM – 5:30 PM ET
The Hyatt Regency Huntington Beach
Huntington Beach, CA
Speaking Engagements
ACI’s 31st Annual Conference on Drug & Medical Device Litigation – 2026
December 2 – 3, 2026
New York Marriott Marquis
1535 Broadway, New York, NY 10036
Speaking Engagements
Entering the Defense Market: USA, Canada, Ukraine, UK, Germany, Poland
November 19, 2026 | 3:00 PM – 5:00 PM CT
Virtual